Nayib Bukele has achieved his many policy victories by being decidedly anti-liberal. He has rejected the advice of the NGO class, the United Nations, the United States and countless other post-war institutions which attempt to push liberalism on the world. In his pursuit of anti-liberal politics and policymaking the El Salvadoran president has made the 6 million people of his small nation more free and drastically increased their opportunities and quality of life. Liberalism and freedom do not go hand in hand, and Mr. Bukele proves this.
Upon taking office Mr. Bukele was faced with a dire situation. 80% of El Salvador was under the control of gangs and drug cartels. The murder rate was the highest in the world, and sexual violence was an aspect of every day life for the nation’s women and girls. In response Bukele took a hard turn away from the liberal prescription for “reform and understanding” and enacted a hardline militarized operation known as the Territorial Control Plan. The cornerstone of the plan was the mass-arrest of some 75,000 suspected gang members and the construction of a prison capable of housing 40,000 inmates in the most spartan of conditions.
The plan worked, decreasing the homicide rate from 36 per 100,000 inhabitants in 2019 (the year Bukele took office) to 2.4 per 100,000 inhabitants in 2023. The United States now boasts a homicide rate more than twice as high as El Salvador, with 5.5 homicides per 100,000 inhabitants in 2023.
Bukele locked gang members up not merely for possession of drugs or firearms, but based on their tattoos or familial connections. “Benefit of the doubt” was taken away from anyone suspected of gang affiliation, and the NGOs roared about the injustice that gang members, murderers and rapists, were facing at the hands of the Bukele government. Amnesty International has referred to Bukele’s crime crackdown as a “human rights crisis” while the Human Rights Watch has called for foreign governments, including the United States, to push against and even sanction El Salvador for its current slate of policies.
Publics, particularly those in the West, have been told for decades that “profiling does not work”, yet profiling criminals based on their traits is exactly what the Bukele administration engaged in, and it transformed his nation only for the better.
Before Bukele rose to power Human Rights Watch rarely if ever commented on El Salvador, despite the massive and systemic violations of human rights by the gangs which controlled the country in the pre-Bukele era. The only substantial piece they ever penned was an article lambasting the United States for deporting illegal immigrants back to the country, because it was too unsafe for deportees. It would seem that Human Rights Watch does not live up to its name, and only cares to enforce liberalism’s worldview.
The institutions of liberalism do not offer, and do not want to offer, actual solutions to the publics of the West, or any other nation for that matter. They have a set of dogmatic beliefs: equity, diversity, “understanding”, and tolerance which supersede all logical policy paths.
Bukele did not seek to “understand” the criminal rapists and murderers of his nation, he set out to protect the public, and it worked.